Kecia Ali and Jonathan A.C. Brown explore the complicated debate over Muhammad, in separate books. The Lives of Muhammad has 68 ratings and 10 reviews. RK-ïsme said: A great book. The author, Kecia Ali, has produced an academic work that does everythi. As Kecia Ali explains, The Lives of Muhammad “is not a book about the life of Muhammad but about the ways in which his life has been told” (1).
|Published:||6 January 2017|
|PDF File Size:||8.13 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||50.31 Mb|
Of particular interest to me were the two chapters on "The Wife of Muhammad" and "Mother of the Faithful", which focus on Khadija and Prof.
Many Views Of Muhammad, As A Man And As A Prophet
Of particular interest to me were the two chapters on "The Wife of Muhammad" and "Mother of the Faithful", which focus on Khadija and Aisha. At least Ali was upfront about this: Instead, Ali is engaging in a kind of comm studies approach, the way the stories of Muhammad are used.
Instead of theoretically unmediated hatditha, Ali looks at different This isn't the book I thought I wanted-- I was interested in kecia ali the lives of muhammad book that would compare collections of haditha, mainly to force me to confront the broad outlines of Muhammad's life enough times that they would stick with me.
Instead of theoretically unmediated hatditha, Ali looks at different "lives," self-conscious presentations of Muhammad's story for particular purposes.
Ali tells Kecia ali the lives of muhammad how changing political and theological concerns have shaped how European Christians described Muhammad's biography, and why the realities of life before the printing press led Muslims to use Muhammad's life story as a lens through which to approach the Quran.
And the things that they had to say about him were very much shaped by what knowledge they did have — much of it inaccurate — but also by current theological, political, social worries.
So that when paganism was a concern, Muhammad was a pagan idol or a god.
When heresy was a concern, Muhammad was akin to a Christian heretic. When fraud and impostors were a concern, Muhammad was a fraud.
The Lives of Muhammad
He was the arch-impostor. Over the centuries, European Christian accounts of Muhammad, in particular, went through a variety of stages and depictions. What begins to happen in the modern era is that European researchers begin to look at Muslim historical chronicles and sources and to merge their scholarly interests with their interest in Christian evangelism.
And those depictions, which claim to be historically accurate and based on early Muslim sources, then engender a reaction from Muslim biographers. On the ongoing debate in the Muslim world: Was Muhammad divine, divinely inspired or a man like any other man?
The Lives of Muhammad — Kecia Ali | Harvard University Press
I kecia ali the lives of muhammad think that the view that has prevailed among Muslims has always been that Muhammad is a man. Since the nineteenth century, two separate streams of writing, one hagiographic and the other polemical, have merged into a single, contentious story about the life of Muhammad.
In the process, texts written symbolically came to be read literally.